Elder Abuse: Is this the same thing as parent abuse?

In June 2006 an article in the Times newspaper reported on  a parliamentary Health Committee inquiry, set up in 2003 and prompted by estimates that up to 50,000 of Britain’s elderly were subject to abuse from relatives and carers. The inquiry declared the abuse of the elderly to be Britain’s “last hidden abuse scandal.” This weekend the Observer has reported on former health minister, Paul Burstow’s concern that figures show as many as 370,000 older people were abused in their home last year  – a “hidden national scandal” – and that the number is likely to increase to nearly half a million by the end of the decade. These figures are based on data extrapolated from a survey of 2000 people in 2007. Nevertheless, they suggest that this is a story that has captured the imagination of those in power.

Frequently when I tell people what I do, they hear “parent abuse” and assume I am talking about “elder abuse”. This fits with the notion that children’s abuse of their parents is too shocking to contemplate, too outside our field of expectation or experience. We hear much more about elder abuse. Initially shocked and disbelieving, the public have taken the idea of elder abuse on board and are generally familiar with what it might mean. There are vocal and well organised campaigning groups to inform the public and influence policy and practice in this area of relationships or social care.

Once I have explained that my interest lies with a younger section of the population, I am asked whether these are the same individuals. Is it the case that the teenagers we see and work with will continue to humiliate, torment, manipulate and terrify their parents as they get older – for the next forty,  fifty years or even longer? Undoubtedly there will be some for whom, tragically, this is the case. A quick look on message boards or TV programmes bringing the horrors of life into our daytime lives offers plenty of examples of families who have lived with abuse and violence from teenagers who are now adult children, continuing long after they have left home.

There will be some who look for links between all forms of family violence. Parent abuse cannot be tied down to one set of circumstances or correlates, and features such as substance use, mental health issues or generalised violence, may also be linked to elder abuse. But we should remember too that there are characteristics that make these two distinct groups. The elderly bring their own vulnerability and may be subject to abuse from carers as well as, or instead of relatives; whereas child to parent violence has by definition a familial aspect, while also inverting traditional understandings of power.

For me one of the most important things to remember though is that the growth in help for families means that parents are not condemned to live with their fear for the rest of their lives. Support programmes – whether based in the statutory or voluntary field, whether working with groups or individuals, whether long standing or just beginning – are showing that the violence and abuse can come to an end, and family relationships be restored. At times when elder abuse is prominent in the news, it seems to me even more important that we should carry this message of hope to the parents with whom we work while campaigning to bring a higher profile nationally to the realities of child to parent violence.

2 Comments

Filed under Discussion, news reports

2 responses to “Elder Abuse: Is this the same thing as parent abuse?

  1. Quite odd to declare any form of abuse to be the last hidden abuse scandal. If others are hidden then we don’t know about them, do we?
    Parent Abuse remains a largely hidden scandal and I would expect that the number are far higher for Parent Abuse than Elder Abuse (not that I’d want to argue that any form of abuse is more important than any other).
    It surprises me that those writing about Elder Abuse in recent years don’t appear to be aware of the work being done on Parent Abuse. I’m not aware of any comparison of the two forms of family violence. I think the dynamics are quite different and, although there will be some overlap in the characteristics of the abusers, I don’t think they are often the same people. One major difference is that abuse of the elderly fits the expected pattern of the more powerful abusing the less powerful. Parent Abuse breaks this pattern and I think this is one reason people are so loath to see it and many academics don’t want to consider it.
    I’m very cynical about any statistics about family violence as they often define ‘abuse’ so widely that it shades into disrespect, neglect and common bad behaviour, missing the patterns of an abusive relationship, but making for dramatic numbers. This is why much survey research makes gender disappear and often makes it look as if most family violence is mutual violence.

    • Hi Eddie
      Thanks for your comment and contribution to the discussion. I remember being surprised in 2006 that anything could be described as the “last hidden abuse scandal”. We have of course seen many since then, but as you say parent abuse still doesn’t capture the headlines in the same way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s